A Collaboration between Trudy Seeger (Sections 1-2) and Tony Wong (Sections 3-4)
Terminating a business presents several challenges, notably in terms of debt and liability management, as well as the protection of intellectual property and other essential assets. On the one hand, you want to satisfy creditor claims, liquidate assets, ensure tax responsibilities are satisfied, and address employment law issues while avoiding or minimizing personal liability. On the other end, you want to make sure that your most valuable intellectual property is safe, laying the groundwork for future recovery or new endeavors. Read on to learn more.
Topics Will be Covered in This Post:
IV. Conclusion
Managing Assets and Liabilities After Early Business Termination
Closing a business is a complex process with various financial obligations that need careful management. Debts, taxes, and other liabilities don’t simply vanish when the doors close. Business owners must navigate legal and financial pathways to avoid future complications, including personal liability for unresolved debts. In this Section, we’ll explore how to handle creditor claims, liquidate assets, and manage debts when shutting down a business prematurely.
1. Understanding Business Debts and Liabilities
When you decide to terminate your business early, the first step is gaining a clear understanding of your business debts and liabilities. This includes unpaid loans, vendor invoices, payroll taxes, leases, and other financial and employment law obligations. Make sure to identify every party the business owes money to—creditors, suppliers, employees, and the government—and organize these debts by priority.
2. Settling Creditor Claims
Once your business is closed, creditors will expect to be paid, even if you are no longer operating. To avoid legal actions, you must notify your creditors of your business closure and work to settle outstanding claims. This can be done through:
Negotiation: Many creditors may be open to negotiating lower repayment amounts if they believe the business cannot meet its original obligations. It's important to approach them early to propose a settlement plan.
Payment in Full: If your business has enough liquid assets, settling all debts in full may be the best route. This ensures that there are no lingering obligations.
Partial Settlements: In some cases, especially when assets are limited, you may need to offer partial payments to creditors. This may not settle the debt entirely, but it will show good faith efforts.
3. Liquidating Business Assets
Selling off business assets is often necessary to cover the outstanding debts. The liquidation process involves selling equipment, inventory, and any other valuable assets your business may own. Here are some key steps:
Appraise Your Assets: Get a professional valuation of all tangible and intangible assets to ensure you understand their worth.
Prioritize Debts: Use the proceeds from asset sales to pay off high-priority debts first, such as secured loans or outstanding taxes.
Legal Considerations: Ensure that the liquidation is done legally and that proceeds are distributed fairly among creditors, especially if bankruptcy proceedings are involved.
4. Tax Obligations
Even if your business closes early, taxes still need to be paid. These can include:
Income Taxes: Your business is responsible for paying income taxes on any earnings made during its last year of operation.
Payroll Taxes: Make sure all payroll taxes are fully paid, as failure to do so can result in serious penalties.
Sales Taxes: If your business has been collecting sales tax, ensure that all payments have been remitted to the relevant authorities.
Consult a tax professional to ensure you meet all your tax obligations and avoid any future liabilities.
5. Avoiding Personal Liability
One of the most important aspects of closing a business is avoiding personal liability for the company’s debts. If your business is a sole proprietorship or partnership, your personal assets could be at risk. However, if the business is structured as a limited liability company (LLC) or corporation, personal liability is generally shielded.
To protect yourself:
Comply with Legal Procedures: Follow the proper procedures for dissolving your business to ensure that creditors cannot come after you personally.
Separate Personal and Business Finances: Ensure that your personal finances are clearly separated from the business to avoid being held liable for business debts.
6. Bankruptcy as a Last Resort
If your business debts are overwhelming and liquidation doesn't cover your obligations, filing for bankruptcy may be the best option. Bankruptcy allows businesses to discharge certain debts and get a fresh start, but it can also have long-term implications for your credit and ability to start a new business in the future. It's important to consult with a financial expert or attorney to understand your options.
Section Summary
Winding Up a business involves numerous challenges, particularly when it comes to managing debts and liabilities. By settling creditor claims, liquidating assets, and ensuring tax obligations are met, you can wrap up your business’s affairs responsibly. Most importantly, taking steps to avoid personal liability can protect you from financial repercussions down the road.
Seeking professional advice, whether from an accountant, lawyer, or financial advisor, can make this process smoother and help you avoid costly mistakes.
Click here to contact HTW Law - Employment Lawyer for assistance and legal consultation.
If you find yourself dealing with business-related issues or accidents involving company vehicles, consulting with truck accident lawyers can provide additional legal guidance to ensure you’re fully protected.
II. Protecting Intellectual Property and Key Assets in Business Termination
When a business is forced to terminate operations, the process involves more than just closing its doors and saying goodbye to employees. Among the most crucial aspects to address is the protection and management of key assets, particularly intellectual property (IP) like patents, copyrights, trademarks, and trade secrets. These assets can retain significant value even after the business ceases to exist. Handling them properly can create opportunities for future revenue, mitigate losses, and protect the business owner’s interests.
In this Section, we will explore how to safeguard valuable assets during business termination, focusing on intellectual property and other key elements like patents and brand rights. We will also examine options for selling or licensing these assets post-termination.
1. The Importance of Protecting Intellectual Property During Business Termination
Intellectual property often holds more value than physical assets like equipment or real estate, especially in industries such as technology, fashion, or entertainment. Patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets provide businesses with a competitive edge and can continue to generate revenue even after the business is no longer operational. However, without proper protection, these intangible assets can become vulnerable to misuse or theft.
One of the first steps in protecting IP during business termination is to review all contracts, licenses, and legal protections in place. This includes ensuring that all relevant trademarks, copyrights, and patents are up to date and valid. Any lapses in protection could lead to the unintentional loss of ownership over these assets.
2. Safeguarding Patents and Trademarks
If your business owns patents or trademarks, it’s essential to maintain their protection during the termination process. Patents, which protect unique inventions, and trademarks, which safeguard your brand identity, can continue to hold value. The options for handling these assets include:
Selling the Assets: If you are closing the business and do not plan to use the intellectual property, selling patents or trademarks to another entity may provide financial recovery. Many businesses, especially competitors or those in adjacent industries, may be interested in acquiring your intellectual property for their own use.
Licensing the IP: Another option is to license your intellectual property to other businesses. This allows you to maintain ownership while still generating revenue from the use of your IP. Licensing agreements can be structured to fit the needs of both parties and can continue to bring in income long after the business has terminated.
Enforcing Legal Protections: If any party attempts to infringe on your IP during the termination process, it is critical to take legal action promptly. Your intellectual property attorney can assist with filing lawsuits or cease-and-desist orders to protect your rights.
3. Protecting Copyrights and Trade Secrets
Copyrights protect the original content your business produces, such as software, designs, literature, or marketing materials. Even if the business terminates, these works remain protected for a certain period, and you have the right to control their use. You can sell or license the copyrights to another party or retain ownership if you plan to continue using them in some capacity.
Trade secrets are another key asset that needs safeguarding during business termination. Trade secrets include confidential business information, such as processes, formulas, or customer lists, that provide a competitive advantage. To protect trade secrets, ensure they are not disclosed in any final business dealings or shared with unauthorized parties. It’s also crucial to revoke access to trade secrets from former employees or partners who may no longer have a legitimate reason to access that information.
4. Post-Termination Options: Selling or Licensing Key Assets
After the termination of a business, there are still viable options for utilizing the intellectual property and key assets that remain. These include:
Selling Patents and Trademarks: Once the business is no longer operational, patents and trademarks can be sold as part of an asset liquidation strategy. Depending on the value of the IP, this can provide a significant financial cushion.
Licensing Intellectual Property: Another profitable avenue is to license intellectual property, such as patents or copyrights, to other businesses. Licensing agreements can generate a steady stream of revenue without relinquishing full ownership of the IP.
Assigning IP Rights to a New Entity: If the business owner plans to start a new venture, transferring the intellectual property rights to the new business ensures that valuable assets remain within their control.
Fire Restoration Companies and IP: In cases where the business is being terminated due to unforeseen circumstances, such as natural disasters or fire damage, it’s essential to understand the value of assets that can still be recovered. In these situations, a fire restoration company can help salvage physical assets, but intellectual property often remains unaffected by physical destruction. Ensuring the legal protection of these intangible assets becomes even more critical during a business recovery process.
5. Key Considerations for Business Owners
Consult Legal Professionals: Navigating the legal aspects of protecting intellectual property and key assets can be complex, especially during the sensitive time of business termination. Business owners should seek the advice of legal professionals who specialize in IP law to ensure they are following the proper steps and maximizing the value of their assets.
Conduct a Thorough IP Audit: Before shutting down operations, perform an audit of all intellectual property owned by the business. This will help determine the value of each asset and whether it is worth selling, licensing, or maintaining.
Stay Proactive in Protecting IP: Even after a business closes, intellectual property can continue to generate value if properly managed. Being proactive in protecting these assets will prevent their misuse or loss and may provide the business owner with much-needed financial recovery after the business terminates.
Section Summary
The termination of a business can be a difficult and emotional process, but it’s crucial not to overlook the importance of protecting intellectual property and other key assets. Whether through selling, licensing, or retaining these assets, business owners can safeguard their value and create future opportunities. Even in challenging circumstances, such as fire damage or financial crises, it’s essential to consider all options for protecting the assets that continue to hold value.
By working with professionals and considering all available options, business owners can ensure that their most valuable intellectual property remains secure, providing a foundation for potential recovery or new ventures in the future.
Click here to contact HTW Law - Employment Lawyer for assistance and legal consultation.
III. Employment Law in Related to Mass Termination and Winding Up
Mass Termination, Bankruptcy and insolvency are complicated areas of law and the specific actions that one can take in Ontario will depend on each case.
Mass Termination in Ontario
A “mass termination” happens when an employer let go of a large number of employees within a prescribed time frame.
a. Who Is Eligible?
Mass Termination is defined in s. 58 of the Employment Standards Act ("ESA"). A "mass termination" happens when an employer dismisses 50 or more workers is terminated at an employer's business establishment (which may be several locations) during a four-week period, usually for economic reasons or restructuring.
Pursuant to s. 1 and s. 53.2 of the ESA, for the purpose of determining mass termination entitlement, “establishment”, with respect to an employer, means a location at which the employer carries on business but, if the employer carries on business at more than one location, separate locations constitute one establishment if:
the separate locations are located within the same municipality, or
one or more employees at a location have seniority rights that extend to the other location under a written employment contract (e.g. if the person has to travel to different locations to perform the job functions), or
the employee performs work in his or her home exclusively. The "private residence" rule only applies to employees who work from home exclusively.
The mass-termination rules do not apply if:
The number of employees terminated represents no more than 10% of the employees who have been employed for at least three months at the establishment; and
None of the terminations are the result of the employer's permanent discontinuance of all or part of its business at the establishment.
b. Required Notice to Director of Employment Standards
Pursuant to s. 58(2) of the ESA, an employer is required to provide the Director of Employment Standards a Form 1 Notice of Termination of Employment.
The notice of termination will not take effect until the Director of Employment Standards receives Form 1 or the effective date denoted in Form 1, whichever is later.
Form 1 must also be posted at the workplace.
Pursuant to Section 6 of the O. Reg. 288/01: Termination and Severance of Employment, fixed term temporary work may be provided to the employee without providing a further notice of termination if the last day of work is not longer than 13 weeks after the termination date specified in the original Form 1 notice.
c. ESA Termination Pay in Mass Termination Scenario
The amount of notice required in a mass termination under the ESA for termination pay is determined not by the workers' length of service, but by the number of employees who have been dismissed, pursuant to Section 3(1) of the O. Reg. 288/01: Termination and Severance of Employment.
Eight weeks' notice if the employment of 50 to 199 workers is to be terminated;
12 weeks' notice if the employment of 200 to 499 employees is to be terminated; and
16 weeks' notice if the employment of 500 or more employees is to be terminated.
It doesn't matter how long an employee has worked. Even if an employee had only been working for two days at the time of termination, the person is still entitled to the prescribed notice of termination or payment instead of notice.
d. ESA Severance Pay in Mass Termination Scenario
Employees who loss their job because of the mass termination are entitled to severance pay on top of the termination pay mentioned above.
Please note that the standard statutory severance pay provisions under the ESA continues to apply in mass termination situations. You are entitled to one week of severance compensation every year of employment, up to a maximum of 26 weeks.
e. Mass Termination Under the Common Law
Under Common law, there's no distinction between mass termination and termination under normal circumstances. The same rules for wrongful dismissal and constructive dismissal applies.
Articles that Might be of Interest to You:
Federal Bankruptcy Law in Related to Employment Law in Canada
Bankruptcy law is subject to federal jurisdiction, and the following federal statutes may apply to you if you hare owed wages due to bankruptcy and / or insolvency:
a. Employer Is Bankrupt or in Receivership
If your employer filed for bankruptcy or is in receivership and they owe you wages, vacation pay, termination pay and severance pay, if applicable, contact either:
your company’s trustee
your company’s receiver
Service Canada
You will likely receive a package of information from a trustee or court-appointed receiver.
The package will guide you on how to file a proof of claim in a bankruptcy and insolvency proceeding. A proof of claim is a form you fill out that helps establish your claim. The trustee or receiver may be able to help you complete it.
In some circumstances, if you have filed a proof of claim for unpaid wages in a bankruptcy or receivership, and the claim has not been paid, you can also file a claim under the Employment Standards Act.
When your employer is bankrupt or in receivership, an employment standards officer may have the power to investigate:
if your employer is a corporation. Directors of a corporation may be found liable for certain unpaid wages (with the exception of unpaid termination or severance pay) if a proof of claim was filed in a bankruptcy/receivership and it has not been paid (s. 81 of ESA)
if, under the ESA, a separate employer is a “related employer” to an insolvent business. The related employer may have liability for unpaid wages (s. 4 of ESA)
You may also want to take a look at the following article that deals with similar issues such as Director Liabilities and legal liabilities of successor company, under the ESA and the Common Law:
b. Employer Is Insolvent
If your employer owes creditors more than $5 million, they can try to rearrange their debts to avoid bankruptcy. Under the federal Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) the courts will appoint a monitor to supervise the company’s restructuring.
You should contact the CCAA monitor for information and help in recovering the money you are owed. Contact information for monitors is available on the Public Registry.
If an employer is involved in CCAA proceedings, an employment standards officer may be prevented from taking action against the employer and/or its directors.
Please Read the Following Article from the Government of Canada to learn about about CCAA Proceedings:
c. Wage Earner Protection Program (WEPP)
i. Overview of WEPP?
If you employer has filed for bankruptcy, is subject to a receivership, or another insolvency proceeding, and you have lost your job and are owed wages, you may be eligible to receive payment under the federal Wage Earner Protection Program (WEPP).
The Wage Earner Protection Program (WEPP) provides for the payment of outstanding eligible wages to individuals whose employer is bankrupt, subject to a receivership, or other WEPP qualifying insolvency proceeding within the meaning of subsection 243(2) of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act.
Employees can receive a one-time payment of up to an amount equivalent to 7 times the maximum weekly insurable earnings under the Employment Insurance Act ($8,507.66 for 2024).
All inquiries regarding the WEPP, including how much you could receive and eligibility requirements, should be made to Service Canada. Visit the WEPP webpage or call the WEPP information line at 1-866-683-6516 for the most up-to-date information on the eligibility period.
Click here for a comprehensive Guide on WEPP from the Government of Canada Website.
ii. What to do if your employer's business closes and there is no trustee or receiver appointed?
If there is no bankruptcy, receivership, or other WEPP qualifying insolvency proceeding, you are not eligible for the WEPP. However, you may ask for help under federal or provincial Labour Standards legislation. You will find contact information for provincial and territorial Labour Standards offices for your area.
iii. Who Is Eligible?
You may be eligible to receive a payment under the Wage Earner Protection Program Act if:
your employer has filed for bankruptcy, is subject to receivership, or another WEPP qualifying insolvency proceeding, such as:
specific proposals under the Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act (BIA) (Division 1 Part III)
certain Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) proceedings
certain foreign proceedings
you have lost your job and your employer owes you wages, vacation pay, termination pay or severance pay
A trustee or receiver will be named to handle your former employer’s bankruptcy, receivership, or other WEPP qualifying insolvency proceeding file.
To claim Under WEPP, you must first submit a "proof of claim" form to:
your company’s trustee in bankruptcy or your company’s receiver (if your former employer Is Bankrupt or in Receivership), or
your company’s Court appointed CCAA monitor (if your former employer Is Insolvent)
You will need to file a proof of claim with the trustee or receiver as soon as possible or it will cause delay to your WEPP application.
The WEPP is administered by the Minister of Labour through Service Canada. WEPPA applications must be submitted to Service Canada within 56 days of either from the date of bankruptcy or receivership or from the date employment ended.
Click here to apply for WEPP. through the Service Canada Website.
The employee does not need to have the proof of claim returned to them (approved, varied, or denied by the trustee or receiver) to apply for WEPP. So don't wait or it may cause delay or affect your WEPP application.
iv. Who Is NOT Eligible?
You are not eligible if, during the period for which you are owed eligible wages, you:
were an officer or a director of the former employer
had a controlling interest in the business of the former employer
were a manager whose responsibilities included:
making binding financial decisions impacting the business of your former employer, and/or
making binding decisions on the payment or non-payment of wages by your former employer
were related to any of the persons mentioned above
You are also not eligible for WEPP if your employer has not yet filed for bankruptcy, or is not subject to a receivership, or other WEPP qualifying insolvency proceeding, you are not eligible for the WEPP.
v. Eligibility Period
The wages, other than termination pay and severance pay, owed to you must have been earned during the eligibility period. The WEPP eligibility period is the 6-month period before the bankruptcy or receivership, or other qualifying insolvency proceedings.
Common Employers / Related Employers
a. Under Common Law
The common employer doctrine under Common Law allows the Court to treat various legal entities as a single employer for liabilities such as outstanding wages, termination pay or severance pay.
i. O'Reilly v. ClearMRI Solutions Ltd., 2021 ONCA 385
The employee's employer owed him a substantial amount of money when he was terminated, and he sued his employer and a major shareholder of his employer for damage.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario reviewed several relevant factors to determine whether a common employer relationship exists between separate legal entities, namely:
where the effective control over the employee resides (e.g., what level of control does an alleged related employer have over the employee);
the language of any employment agreement (e.g., are their indications of one entity or multiple entities being the employer); and
whether there was common control between the different legal entities.
whether there is a clear intention between the employee and the corporation alleged to be a common employer to create an employer-employee relationship.
The Court of Appeal found that there was no such intention between the employee and the major shareholder to create an employment relationship and as such the Common law employer doctrine is not applicable.
ii. Krmpotic v. Thunder Bay Electronics Limited, 2024 ONCA 332
Drago Krmpotic worked as a Building Maintenance Supervisor for Thunder Bay Electronics Limited (TBEL) and Hill Street Financial Services (HSFS) for nearly 30 years.
The Court of Appeal held TBEL and HSFS jointly and severally liable for the damages awarded to Krmpotic.
In finding TBEL and HSFS to be Common Employers, the Court pointed to the following:
Employment History: Krmpotic’s employment involved duties that served both TBEL and HSFS, and his work was intertwined with the operations of both companies. For instance, TBEL was responsible for television broadcasting, while Hill Street provided administrative and accounting services and owned the building where TBEL operated. Krmpotic’s role in building maintenance and vehicle fleet management was crucial to the functioning of both companies.
Company Records and Testimony: The court relied on testimony from Don Caron, a key witness who held leadership roles in both TBEL and Hill Street, to establish that Krmpotic’s employment was considered to be under both entities. Caron’s affidavit indicated that Krmpotic’s employment had been transferred between the two companies several times, further blurring the lines between the two employers.
Settlement Memorandum: The Settlement Memorandum offered to Krmpotic at the termination meeting explicitly named both TBEL and Hill Street as his employers. This document, drafted by the employers themselves, was clear evidence that both companies considered themselves jointly responsible for Krmpotic’s employment.
b. Under ESA
Section 4 of the ESA sets out when separate persons may be treated as one employer for the purposes of the Employment Standards Act.
According to s.4 of the ESA, in determining whether two entities are associated or related, one should consider the following significant criteria. They are listed in descending order of significance with the most important factor listed first:
Common management
Common financial control
Common ownership
Existence of common trade name or logo
Movement of employees between two or more entities
Use of same assets by two or more entities, or transfer of assets between them
Common market or customers served by the two or more entities
This list is not exhaustive; there may be other relevant factors in the context of a particular case.
Please read the policy interpretation guideline below for a detail discussion of the criteria listed above as per s. 4 of the ESA:
Benefits Under Employment Insurance (EI) in Ontario
Employment Insurance (EI) provides regular benefits to any and all workers who lose their jobs through no fault of their own (e.g. due to shortage of work, seasonal or mass lay-offs) and are ready and able to work, but CANNOT find a job.
As an employee, you should apply for employment insurance benefits as soon as you stop working. Don't wait for your severance pay to come!! Apply within 4 weeks of your final day at work or you might not be eligible if you wait longer.
As an employer, you are required to issue an Record of Employment (ROE) each time one of your employees experiences an interruption of earnings, and file the ROE with Service Canada. If you fail to issue the ROE as required, you may face a $2,000 fine, up to 6 months in jail, or both.
Employees are not require to wait for the ROE from the employer to start an EI claim. But the EI payments may be delayed if your employer does not file the ROE with Service Canada.
Click here for a comprehensive guide on EI benefits from the Government of Canada.
IV. Conclusion
Winding up a business is a complex process that requires careful attention to legal, financial, and operational matters. Properly addressing contractual obligations, respecting employee rights, protecting intellectual property, and adhering to local laws are all crucial steps aiming to ensure compliance and avoid personal liability. By working closely with legal and financial advisors, business owners can navigate these challenges effectively, safeguarding valuable assets for future endeavors.
You may want to consult with an experienced employment law firm, such as HTW Law, to learn about the DO and Don't in employment law context to ensure that all angles are covered as an employer.
On the other hands, as an employee you MUST be made aware of your legal entitlements in a business winding up context to safeguard your employment rights.
Speaking with an employment lawyer who understands the nuances of employment law in Ontario in light of a mass termination or winding up will go a long way. If you are in doubt, it's essential that you reach out for help before it's too late.
Click here to contact HTW Law - Employment Lawyer for assistance and legal consultation.
Author Bio:
Trudy Seeger is a seasoned freelance content writer with extensive experience in crafting insightful articles for prominent legal blogs and websites. He specializes in creating content that simplifies complex legal topics, ranging from personal injury and employment law to contract disputes and intellectual property. With a keen focus on how legal developments impact businesses and individuals, Trudy has a proven track record of delivering well-researched, engaging, and informative legal content.
Staff Writer - Tony Wong